Tenant Management

Top credit screening services for landlords

woman at laptop using top credit screening services for landlords

The ability to run screening reports on prospective tenants is one of the most powerful tools landlords have when it comes to choosing great renters. Used correctly, this information helps confirm applicant identity, evaluate financial fitness, and get an overview of rental and employment histories. The top credit screening services for landlords provide all this and more. We’ll discuss the range of information available to landlords, how to factor this into a decision-making process, and what other steps to take before accepting a tenant. 

We all want tenants who pay on time, co-exist well with those around them, and take care of our property. Screening the credit, employment, and rental history of prospective tenants is invaluable in the process of selecting the best tenants

Also Read: How To Screen Tenants in 7 Easy Steps

Landlord or Tenant – who orders the report?

While it is possible for landlords to order screening reports, there are several benefits to having applicants order and pay directly for credit screening reports. In our experience, tenants like making payment directly as opposed to handing over cash or a check, and as an added benefit they may also be able to see and/or share the reports once they’ve made the purchase. Landlords are also better off this way because it gets around the need to receive and store hard copies of sensitive personal information such as social security numbers.  In addition, savings in time are attractive, as it is not necessary to collect screening fees and order reports. Online rental management tools have the added benefit of making applications accessible from anywhere, and archived in the landlord’s account.

Getting started with a credit screening service

If you decide to use tenant credit screening services as part of your screening process (and, obviously, we suggest you do), then the first step is to get permission — in writing — from the prospective tenant to access their financial and personal information. Good applications should incorporate this authorization into the signing of the form. 

Deciding who pays for and orders screening reports is another strategic consideration. Therefore we believe the best approach is to have the tenant both apply and purchase screening reports through an online service of your choosing. Recommendation: do not accept forwarded or printed reports from other sources, as they can be faked, altered, or be for someone different entirely.  

Key benefits of using credit screening services

The best credit check services for landlords provide credit screening and background reports help landlords assess prospective tenants by offering the following:

  1. Metrics suggesting how a person approaches paying bills and meeting commitments, based on their payment history.
  2. Indicators on the applicant’s ability to pay the rent.  Landlords often use a rule-of-thumb that a tenant should not be accepted if the rent is more than 1/3 of total income.  More relevant, in our opinion, is whether a tenant can cover rent and other debts on a monthly basis.  A credit screening report will show you whether an applicant has a sufficient income-to-debt level to cover all expenses.
  3. An outline of financial liabilities such as car loans, mortgages, and credit card debts.
  4. A window into a person’s life path where it comes to career trajectory and housing track record.
  5. Help confirming identity and detecting fraud, by linking social security numbers with birth date, residence history, and financial records.

Also Read: The Best Tenant Screening Service for Small Landlords

We suggest you use one of many online services that provide not only credit screening reports, but access to background and criminal information, as well as other tools such as online applications and rent collection. Please take a look at our list of top credit screening services for landlords.

  • An industry leader in tenant screening, RentPrep offers a selection of reports starting at $21.
  • Hand compiled Judgements and Liens reports available
  • Opt for a simplified Credit Check instead of full TransUnion Credit Report
  • Unique Income Verification feature
  • Strength: Tenant Screening
  • Tenant screening solution perfect for independent landlords. Screen tenants, market your vacancies, and take applications for free.
  • Strength: Tenant Screening
  • Advertise your property, find and screen tenants, sign leases, collect rent, and e-sign custom local leases, with tools built specifically for DIY landlords.
  • Strength: Complete Solution

In practice:  Using the information screening reports provide

Credit Data:

When choosing a tenant credit check service, or reading a report you’ve received, we recommend you look for the following indicators of financial fitness:

  1. Credit score. You may want to set a minimum score or a threshold below — which you require a larger deposit or a co-signer. For example, you might want to set criteria such as:  <550 not considered, 550-650 conditional, >650 acceptable.
  2. Recent credit applications, which may be a sign that an applicant is having trouble with cash flow or is open to taking on more debt.
  3. Number of accounts open and the amount of available credit, which suggests how much debt an applicant could quickly and easily take on.
  4. Existing credit balances, and the associated required monthly payments.  This is very important in evaluating how much of a prospect’s income is available to be paid in rent.
  5. Missed or late payments.
  6. Collections or accounts closed with a balance due.
  7. Bankruptcies
  8. Foreclosures

Background Details:

Good screening reports can also provide a range of useful information aside from specifics on credit history and debt.  We suggest you look for reports that provide the following:

  1. Residence and employment history:
    • Look for longer tenures and consider carefully if there has been excessive moving around.
  2. Identity fraud indicators:
    • Some reports feature prominent warnings about potential fraud, while it’s necessary to look more carefully for signs on others.  
    • Some indicators to look for are newly issued Social Security numbers and residence history that doesn’t match the information you’ve been provided by the applicant.
  3. Background information:
    • Evictions
    • Lawsuits
    • Judgments
  4. Criminal Record:
    • *Note that localities such as Seattle now disallow consideration of this as criteria. Make sure you are aware of local laws.
    • Sex-Offender registry
    • Terrorist watch list
    • A record of national and local arrests and convictions

Potential red flags when screening a tenant

As you analyze the information you’ve received take heed of the various potential red flags, which could be good reason to decline an applicant:

  1. Evictions, bankruptcies or foreclosures where new positive history hasn’t been established.
  2. High debt-to-earning ratio
  3. Insufficient income to cover rent
  4. Chronic or recent late payments
  5. Collections
  6. Lack of verifiable employment
  7. Lack of verifiable rental history, or derogatory feedback having communicated with past landlords.
  8. Criminal convictions
    1. * You may want to consider surrounding circumstances, what type of offense it was, and how long ago the conviction occurred.                                                

Next steps

Once you’ve reviewed the credit screening report we always recommend that you take the following steps before offering a unit to a new renter: 

  1. Call rental references
  2. Call employment references
  3. Interview applicant about the backstory for any information that isn’t clear or that is concerning.


Many online services bundle credit and background screening with features that help the tenant management process.  As we’ve noted, many have additional benefits such as marketing tools, applications, rent collection, lease documents, and maintenance management features.  It is often possible to find free software tools, with reasonable additional fees for added features, if desired.  In our business the safety, ease, and efficiency these products offer are highly beneficial.  We encourage you to research a service that is right for you.

Rental Property Management Software

For many landlords the right property management software can help you efficiently run your small business. We have evaluated some of today’s top software products to uncover their key benefits. Let us help you find landlord software that is best suited for your needs. Whether you are looking for tools to help collect rent, screen tenants, list your rental, automate your record keeping, or other property management tasks, we can find a product for you:

Disclosure: Some of the links in this post are affiliate links and Landlord Gurus may earn a commission. Our mission remains to provide valuable resources and information that helps landlords manage their rental properties efficiently and profitably. We link to these companies and their products because of their quality, not because of the commission.

Spread the love
Tagged , , , , , , ,

About Eli Secor

Eli Secor, Co-Founder, Landlord Gurus Eli purchased his first rental property at the age of 20, a fourplex in Gold Canyon, Arizona. He was lucky to have the advice of a shrewd real estate investing grandmother, as well as special incentives for first time buyers following the savings and loan meltdown in the late ‘80’s. In 2004 Eli and his wife purchased their first property together, a triplex in Portland, Oregon. The neighborhood was improving, light rail was coming in, and the property needed a significant rehab. They traveled back and forth from their then home in California, improving and managing the property. Eli did a full remodel on the biggest unit, living in the construction zone while doing so. The property has been cashflow positive since day one, and is now worth 3-4 times its original purchase price. Eli has been involved in residential construction since 2001, having remodeled several houses from top to bottom, rehabbed or improved rental units, and built his family’s primary residence. He leverages his knowledge of buildings to improve and maintain rental properties cost and time-effectively. Since 2007 Eli has been managing property in Seattle for family members, and now oversees 20 apartments and 3 commercial spaces. He has a great handyman, who helps make repairs, maintenance, and improvement smooth and easy. Otherwise Eli is a DIY landlord, and single contact for all of his tenants.When Eli isn’t managing rental property he is working on home projects, sailing, mountain biking, skiing, or spending time with friends and family. Once or twice a week Chris and Eli get together to run their dogs, Lola & Peanut. These meetings do double duty as Landlord Gurus planning sessions!Credentials: - BA in History from Whitman College - General Contractor (Ex) - USCG Licensed Captain (UOPV Six-Pack)
View all posts by Eli Secor →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *