Updated January 4th 2023: New and higher quality reference materials relating to emotional support animal housing laws were added to the article
As the willingness of doctors to prescribe emotional support animals (ESA) continues to increase, landlords are struggling to understand the emotional support animal housing laws. Navigating how to protect your property against damage, handling threats ESAs can have to other tenants, and the confusion between emotional support animals vs traditional service animals has never been more complicated.
Also Read: Emotional Support Animals and Pets In Your Rental: Landlord Gurus Experience
Questions a landlord might ask:
- Do I have to accept emotional support animal in my rental?
- What fees can I charge?
- Which questions can I ask about a tenant’s need for an ESA?
- What proof can I require that my tenant is eligible for an emotional support animal?
- Is an ESA a service animal, and what are the differences?
This article will help sort through common questions and outline your responsibilities and rights when renting to someone with an emotional support animal.
Related Read: Landlords: Choosing the Best Pet Fee for Rental Property
Service vs Emotional Support Animal Housing Laws
It is easy to confuse emotional support animals with service animals, however there are some key differences between the two. One of the main differences revolves around specified training that the animal has received.
Emotional Support Animals
Emotional support animals do not need any specific training, and don’t usually have any. Their primary function is to provide companionship, emotional support, or assistance to those with a disability as defined by a tenant’s licensed health care provider. Those prescribed ESA could suffer from anxiety, depression, or PTSD for example.
Emotional support animal housing laws are narrow and do not extend to legal protections in businesses, places of work, or transportation facilities.
Service Animals
Conversely, service animals do in fact receive special training to perform tasks for their owners that would not be able to perform those same tasks on their own.
Think of service animals the same way you would a necessary medical device such as a wheelchair or prosthetic limb. For example, epileptics often have dogs trained to sense an oncoming seizure, before their owner is aware one is about to happen. Service animals also help a variety of people who do not have physical disabilities. They also perform essential functions for individuals with mental or emotional disabilities as well.
Contrary to popular belief service animals do not have to be certified or registered, although many owners choose to do so. The Americans With Disabilities Act (ADA) also does not require owners to provide proof that a service animal has been formally certified, trained, or licensed.
Also Read: How To Screen Tenants in 7 Easy Steps
Also Read: The Best Free Property Management Software for Small Landlords in 2021
How to Verify a Tenant with an Emotional Support Animal
Potential tenants applying to rent from you that have an emotional support animal must be able to provide proof that the animal has been prescribed appropriately. Emotional support animals are prescribed by medical or mental health care professionals in most cases. Given appropriate proof you cannot disqualify a tenant from renting from you simply because they have an emotional support animal. Consequently, this applies even if you have a no-pets policy.
Emotional Support Animal Letter
In most cases, a tenant provides an “Emotional Support Animal Letter” to their landlord as means of demonstrating their disability, and the disability-related need for a support animal.
An ESA letter is a signed statement from the tenant’s doctor, psychologist, social worker, or other medical professional or reliable third-party.
A landlord may require documentation, in writing that:
- The tenant or a member of his or her family is a person with a disability.
- The need for the animal to assist the person with that specific disability.
- The animal actually assists the person with a disability.
HUD does not specify or limit the disabilities that apply to emotional support animal housing laws, and landlords may not inquire about the existence or severity of a tenant’s disability.
Also Read: The Best Rental Property Management Software: Product Overviews
Understanding Emotional Support Housing Laws
Emotional support animal housing laws, along with those addressing service animals, provide tenants with certain rights and protections that you need to consider as a landlord. It is important to know what actions you can take when renting to a tenant with an emotional support or service animal and which you cannot.
6 Things You Should NOT Do:
Renting to a tenant with an emotional support animal can be complex and stressful, and it’s important to know the actions you should avoid taking and questions you should avoid asking.
1. Ask questions about a person’s disability
- As we’ve discussed above, regarding ESA verification, landlords may not request medical records or details on the nature or severity of a tenant’s disability. See below for questions a landlord may ask.
2. Require Registration
- There is no formal registration or certification process for ESA.
3. Claim “Undue Burden” Except In Extreme Cases
- Our research suggests that courts will use a high bar when landlords claim that accepting an ESA will cause them undue financial or administrative burden.
- We suggest accommodating all reasonable requests, in order to make housing available people who need it, and to avoid the possibility of a legal dispute.
- Animal restrictions placed by a landlord’s insurance carrier are not always cause for denying an ESA. Some insurance companies may have exceptions for ESA and service dogs.
- Unless a fellow tenant has a documented allergy, an ESA cannot be excluded based on allergies.
4. Charge Pet Rents, Fees, Or Deposits
- FHA regulations prohibit landlords from charging increased rent or requiring any sort of deposit for tenants having emotional support animals.
5. Treat ESA as Pets
- Emotional support animal housing laws dictate that normal pet rules may not be applied.
- Emotional support animals are not subject to no-pet policies, breed restrictions, and size restrictions
6. Require Training
- For starters, landlords cannot require an emotional support animal to have any specific type of training.
- Avoid asking for any sort of evidence related to the animal’s training such as a training certification or license..
6 Things You SHOULD Do:
Following are some best practices when dealing with emotional support animal housing laws:
1. Require an emotional support animal letter
- It is within your rights to require this statement before offering housing to a prospective tenant. Essentially this document is verification from an appropriate medical authority, answering the two questions below.
- Some owners have a form of their own, which they require be completed by a medical professional. Whether you’re using your own form, or wanting to ask questions of the professional directly, we recommend consulting a lawyer to make sure you’re legally in the clear.
- Jump up here for a full description of an emotional support animal letter.
2. Document owner responsibilities
- Both service and emotional support animals must be under the control of their owner at all times, whether that be on a leash or tether, or by voice command.
- Care, supervision, and cleanup are the responsibility of the emotional support animal’s owner.
- Emotional support animals must also be housebroken.
Also Read: Understanding Rental Lease Agreements: A Landlord’s Guide
Note: A pet addendum is an important tool when allowing animals in your rentals. For instance, starting with a form such as the one RocketLawyer provides and adapting for emotional support animals could help communicate a tenant’s responsibilities. We recommend using a form such as this form for all animals in your rentals.
3. Request vaccination records
- Landlords have the right to request veterinary records demonstrating that an ESA has been vaccinated and is not a danger to people or pets around them.
4. Consider these two questions:
- “Does the person seeking to use and live with the animal have a defined disability?” I.E., a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities.
- “Does the person making the request have a disability-related need for an assistance animal? Is the animal working, providing assistance, performing tasks, or giving emotional support that alleviates one or more of the identified symptoms or effects of that person’s disability?”
5. Protect your property from damage with a Move-In Move-Out Condition Checklist
- Owners are responsible for the damage their emotional support animals do to your rental property.
- Make sure to use a thorough move-in / move-out checklist to clearly demonstrate the condition of the property before the animal lived there, and after.
- Take photos and videos as visual documentation or look into one of the inspection apps that are now available. We recommend this practice for all tenancies and especially where there is an animal in the unit.
6. Communicate with empathy and openness
- Communicate in a respectful manner and understand that emotional support animals provide real relief to people with a wide range of emotional and psychological disabilities, many of which are not obvious to the casual observer.
Also Read: The Best Tenant Screening Service for Small Landlords
Emotional Support Animals: Species & Breeds
Keep an open mind and remember that ESA do not have to be of any specific breed or variety.
Miniature horses, pigs, turtles, and even llamas can be valid emotional support animals. Other unique breeds have come to include kangaroos, peacocks, and squirrels.
Also Read: Should You List a Rental on Zillow?
Exemptions To Emotional Support Animal Housing Laws
There are two conditions which exempt landlords from their requirement to accept emotional support animals:
- The subject property has 1-4 units and one is owner-occupied.
- The rental is a single-family home rented out without the services of a realtor. In addition, the owner of the home must not own more than three single-family homes.
If your building does not fit into one of these categories, that means you must provide reasonable accommodations to those tenants with emotional support animals, giving them equal opportunity to use and enjoy the property.
Also Read: Avoid costly repairs with a rental property maintenance checklist
Valid Reasons To Deny Tenants with Emotional Support Animals
In some ways, it may seem that tenants hold all the power with respect to emotional support animals. In actuality, there are many acceptable reasons to deny a tenant with emotional support animal housing.
You can deny a tenant with an emotional support animal housing if:
- They are unable to provide sufficient documentation, such as the emotional support animal letter, that verifies the ESA is necessary for their health and well-being.
- The tenant provides fraudulent documentation attesting to their need for an emotional support animal (usually a fake emotional support animal letter).
- The landlord can demonstrate that making accommodations for an ESA would impose undue financial burden or logistical burden. (Careful with this one! The hardship necessary to qualify must be significant and provable.)
- In the case of an illegal breed… maybe. Some cities and states have “Breed-Specific Legislation” which makes it legal to exclude certain species or breeds of animals. Our research suggests that FHA laws supersede local regulations. If you come across this situation make sure to talk to local attorney so that you understand your responsibilities in your location.
- The animal is destructive to the property or displays threatening behaviors that could put other tenants or yourself at risk.
- The size or nature of the animal makes it impossible to house safely our humanely. (We’d certainly seek counsel if a tenant showed up with an alligator or cow, for example.)
Also Read: Residential Lease Agreements: Best Software for Small Landlords
Landlord Gurus Take-Away
Emotional support animals have increased in popularity over the last decade, and there is ample evidence that they provide valuable emotional and psychological support to those with disabilities. In 2011, for example, the National Service Animal Registry listed nearly 2,400 registered emotional support animals and service animals combined. At this point that number sits closer to 200,000.
Landlords need to understand how to handle tenants with these types of companions. Above all, it is important to understand that emotional support animal housing laws are not the same as those relating to pets or service animals. You cannot discriminate against people that own an emotional support animal, but as a landlord you do still have rights. Tenants must be able to provide a valid emotional support animal letter, for example. Landlords are not required to provide housing if an ESA is destructive, threatening, or cannot reasonably be housed humanely due to its weight or size. Furthermore, owners are liable for damages caused by their animals, just as any other tenants would be.
In conclusion, knowing your rights and responsibilities under emotional support animal laws is now more important than ever. If you have any questions or experiences you’d like to share on this topic, please feel free to contact us!
Photos by Stephen Andrews on Unsplash & Philippe Oursel @ Unsplash.com
A Few Of Our Favorite Property Management Tools:
- RentRedi is an all-inclusive landlord-tenant app. Manage vacancies, screening, and rent collection from wherever you are, on any device.
- Strength: Complete Solution
- With no subscription plan and a simple pricing structure, PayRent helps property owners and managers collect rent online safely, reliably and automatically.
- Strength: Rent Collection
- Advertise your property, find and screen tenants, sign leases, collect rent, and e-sign custom local leases, with tools built specifically for DIY landlords.
- Strength: Complete Solution
- Asset management and accounting software for real estate investors, including smart money management, automated income and expense tracking, personalized reporting and more.
- Strength: Accounting and Financial Tracking
Disclosure: Some of the links in this post are affiliate links and Landlord Gurus may earn a commission. Our mission remains to provide valuable resources and information that helps landlords manage their rental properties efficiently and profitably. We link to these companies and their products because of their quality, not because of the commission.
What is the authoritative data/reference source for the Exemptions to the Emotional Support Animal Housing Laws?
Thank you
Hi Jeff,
Thanks for the question. First off, we’re NOT lawyers, so if there is any doubt in your mind about what you need to do to adhere to Emotional Support Animal laws in your location we strongly suggest you consult a lawyer. The best source of information we have is from HUD: https://www.hud.gov/sites/dfiles/PA/documents/HUDAsstAnimalNC1-28-2020.pdf. I hope that helps!
Thanks for visiting Landlord Gurus!
Take Care,
Eli
What if insurance does not cover pet damage, liability.. What if an ESP hurt someone or other property is the landlord liable, there are 3 houses on shared property with no capabilities to separate by fencing, will loose most/ all access/ driveways to houses.. Never had trouble saying no pets allowed before.
Good questions, Sha. Emotional support animals are not considered pets, by the law. So if you deny a tenant because of their ESA, you may be setting yourself up for a discrimination claim under the FHA. However, if you can prove that the animal poses a direct threat to the health or safety of other individuals or whose tenancy would result in substantial physical damage to the property of others, you might be able to refuse the accommodation. “The animal must pose a direct threat that cannot be eliminated or reduced to an acceptable level through actions the individual takes to maintain or control the animal.” Regarding damages, you may charge a tenant for damage an assistance animal causes if it is your usual practice to charge for damage caused by tenants (or deduct it from the standard security deposits imposed on all tenants). In essence, you can charge for damage done IF you also do that for non-disabled tenants.
Are tenant with ESA responsible for defleaing and/or deodorizing the property after the lease is over?
They are responsible for returning the property in the condition it was before they moved in.
Would a short term rental of four months qualify me as a tenant? I am renting from an owner in a trailer park in Florida. Per the bi-laws, pets are okay in certain areas of the park but not in the area of my 2024 rental. My pet would be a small dog, crate trained as well as potty trained.
Do Emotional Support Animals have to be housebroken/potty trained?
Hi David,
While landlords cannot require an emotional support animal to have any specific training, you can require that emotional support animals be under the control of their owner at all times, whether that be on a leash or tether, or by voice command. Care, supervision, and cleanup are the responsibility of the emotional support animal’s owner, and you can require that ESAs are also housebroken. We also suggest you protect your property from damage with a move-in/move-out inspection and document the condition of the property.
We have an existing tenant, in a building that does not allow dogs. He has been with us three years, great guy, knows the rules. He now has a girlfriend, that he says will soon be his fiancé, and they want to move in together. She has a dog. He says it’s an ESA. He also states that he knows that we “…cannot prevent her from moving in with him due to the Fair Housing Act”.
While I understand our hands are somewhat tied with a NEW applicant, this area (existing tenant w no pets for 3 years, that now challenges the house rules) seems very grey to me. He’s coming to the end of his 3rd year (we gladly renewed each year) and knows the house rules. He wants her to move in and while he called to discuss which we appreciate, he’s also taking a hard stance that he really didn’t have to as we cannot say no (for the reasons above), which actually is not the case. Animal or not, we ALWAYS reserve the right to vett and approve any new roommates, (for all of our tenants protection) so he would be in violation if one day she was living there without properly applying…As an established tenant that clearly knew our house policy, isnt this different than a new face coming in and applying for residency?
Scottsdale, AZ
Your tenant’s girlfriend should submit and application and go through your standard tenant screening process. While you cannot deny her for having an ESA, she still needs to pass your background check, and you should add her to the lease so that each of them is responsible for any damages. You can also ask her to submit proof that a service animal is required.
In your article you reference that….
“1. The rental is a single-family home rented out without the services of a realtor. In addition, the owner of the home must not own more than three single-family homes.”
Does this still hold true to the current regulations? I’ve never heard of it. Is it a HUD rule or exculsion?
Thank you
Hi Troy,
Here are references for that law. I do see that the HUD language on this matter is a bit more subjective than the interpretations in the two articles below. It might be good to check with a lawyer if in doubt.
See page 1.
https://www.hud.gov/sites/documents/FHEO_BOOKLET_ENG.PDF
Sources that state the exemptions with certainty.
https://adata.org/legal_brief/assistance-animals-under-fair-housing-act-section-504-rehabilitation-act-and-air
https://pettable.com/blog/can-a-landlord-deny-an-esa#can-your-landlord-deny-an-emotional-support-animal
Thanks for the question!
Eli
Is there a limit to how many “emotional support animals” we have to accept as landlords?
For example- would we have to accept 3 ESA’s for one individual?
Hello DeDe.
As we always emphasize, we are not lawyers and recommend consulting one if ever in doubt. That being said, everything we have read indicates that multiple ESA’s are allowed if each of them is documented properly. We have seen no limit on the number a tenant can have. This article sums up our understanding well: https://www.turbotenant.com/blog/emotional-support-animal-laws/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=ppc&utm_term=&utm_campaign=Property+Management+Pmax&location=9061299&gad_source=1&gclid=CjwKCAjwrcKxBhBMEiwAIVF8rLdWupn1XAqQp9JJoOCYZFORMaOdLRESSzeBHvdaGoCvSnyaiV0RLhoCwbkQAvD_BwE
I hope that helps!
Eli
As a landlord, understanding your obligations regarding Emotional Support Animals (ESAs) can be challenging. There isn’t a specific limit on the number of ESAs a tenant can have, but each animal must be deemed necessary for the individual’s mental health by a licensed mental health professional.
To get more detailed information on this topic, including legal considerations and possible limitations, I recommend reading this comprehensive guide:
https://fastesaletter.com/can-a-landlord-refuse-emotional-support-animals-due-to-breed-weight-or-size/
If a tenant requests an ESA be allowed, does the animal have to follow our animal policy concerning spayed/neutered, noise, etc?